Ryan Reynolds as Monty Anna Faris as Serena Justin Long as Dean David Koechner as Dan Luis Guzmán as Raddimus Chi McBride as Bishop John Francis Daley as Mitch Kaitlin Doubleday as Amy Rob Benedict as Calvin (as Robert Patrick Benedict) Alanna Ubach as Naomi Vanessa Lengies as Natasha Max Kasch as T-Dog Andy Milonakis as Nick Dane Cook as Floyd Jordan Ladd as Danielle Emmanuelle Chriqui as Tyla Wendie Malick as Monty's Mom Monica Monica as Dean's Mom Travis Resor as Chett J.D. Evermore as Redneck (as JD Evermoore) Clay Chamberlin as Video Host (as Clay Chamberlain) Skyler Stone as Cook #1 Melissa Morgan as Bitchy Lady Don Brady as Old Man Anne Ewen as Girl at Bar Pat Hazell as Jack Jordan Werner as Smooth Guy #1 Skylar Duhe as Girly #1 Ann Marie Guidry as Dessert Woman (as Ann Guidry) Lauren Swinney as Elderly Woman Wayne Ferrara as Rocco Richard Netzberger as German #1 Roland W. Hoffman as German #2 Dean Shull as Commenting Guy Melissa Alonzo as Stunt Bush Todd Voltz as Background Cook Robb Conner as Background Cook (as Rob Wagner) Matt as Background Cook Shedric as Background Cook Barbara Balentine as Desert Lady's Friend (uncredited) James L. Bills as Bar Patron / Waiter (uncredited) Victor Brunette as Guy Eating French Fries (uncredited) Justin Groetsch as Restaurant Patron (uncredited) Raymond Lapino as Elderly Restaurant Patron (uncredited) Matthew D. Miller as Party Goer (uncredited) Loronzo Nickleson as Food Model (uncredited) Brian Pitt as Former Manager (uncredited) Shawn Sanz as Restaurant Patron (uncredited) Aaron Sauer as Restaurant Patron (uncredited) Lexi Shoemaker as Restaurant Patron (uncredited) Mathew Waring as Stereo Guy (uncredited)