Rainn Wilson as Robert 'Fish' Fishman Christina Applegate as Kim Teddy Geiger as Curtis Josh Gad as Matt Gadman Emma Stone as Amelia Jeff Garlin as Stan Jane Lynch as Lisa Jason Sudeikis as David Marshall Will Arnett as Lex Howard Hesseman as Gator Fred Armisen as Kerr Bradley Cooper as Trash Lonny Ross as Sticks Jon Glaser as Billy Jane Krakowski as Carol