Dermot Mulroney as Dr. David Henry Gretchen Mol as Nora Henry Emily Watson as Caroline Gil Jamie Spilchuk as Paul - age 18-22 David Gibson McLean as Duke (as David McLean) Krystal Hope Nausbaum as Phoebe Tyler Stentiford as Paul @ 13 Hugh Thompson as Al Jeremy Akerman as The Minister Owen Pattison as Paul - age 6 Kerry McPherson as Kay Emma Colbert as Phoebe 6 years Lita Llewellyn as Ruby Mark A. Owen as Mover (as Mark Owen) David Christoffel as Pete Warren (as David C) Martha Irving as Supervisor Dominique D'Arnell as Little Girl Sandrine Lauzon as Newborn Phoebe Heather Blom as Student Stage Manager Mary Colin Chisolm as David's Mother (as Mary-Colin Chrisolm) Don Ritchie as Board President Brian Heighton as Police Officer Dylan Harman as Robert Catherine O'Connor as Tabitha Molly Dunsworth as Young Woman - 18 years Shawn Duggan as Doctor Sanders Simon Henderson as Billy Susan Leblanc-Crawford as Lee William Stordy as Young David Gay Hauser as Department Store Clerk