Brad Pitt as Mr. O'Brien Sean Penn as Jack Jessica Chastain as Mrs. O'Brien Hunter McCracken as Young Jack Laramie Eppler as R.L. Tye Sheridan as Steve Fiona Shaw as Grandmother Jessica Fuselier as Guide Nicolas Gonda as Mr. Reynolds Will Wallace as Architect Kelly Koonce as Father Haynes Bryce Boudoin as Robert Jimmy Donaldson as Jimmy Kameron Vaughn as Cayler Cole Cockburn as Harry Bates Dustin Allen as George Walsh Brayden Whisenhunt as Jo Bates Joanna Going as Jack's Wife Irene Bedard as Messenger Finnegan Williams as Jack @ 2 Michael Koeth as Jack @ 5 John Howell as R. L. @ 2 Samantha Martinez as Samantha Savannah Welch as Mrs. Kimball Tamara Jolaine as Mrs. Stone Julia M. Smith as Beth Anne Nabors as Rue Christopher Ryan as Prisoner Tyler Thomas as Tyler Stone Michael Showers as Mr. Brown Kimberly Whalen as Mrs. Brown (as Kim Whalen) Margaret Hoard as Jane (as Margaret Ann Hoard) Wally Welch as Clergyman Hudson Lee Long as Mr. Bagley (as Hudson Long) Michael Dixon as Dusty Walsh William Hardy as Jack's Work Colleague Tommy Hollis as Tommy Cooper Franklin Sutherland as Robert #2 John Cyrier as Bi-Plane Pilot Erma Lee Alexander as Erma Nicholas Yedinak as Nicholas Swimmer Jackson Hurst as Uncle Ray Crystal Mantecon as Elisa Erinn Allison as Mrs. Bates (uncredited) Charlotte Biggs as 1950's Woman (uncredited) Benjamin Dane as Symphony Patron (uncredited) Alex Draguicevich as (voice) (uncredited) Michael E. Harvey as Lame Man (uncredited) Matt Hislope as Clown (uncredited) Zach Irsik as Jack's Son (uncredited) Scott Jefferies as Businessman (uncredited) Jodie Moore as Mr. Walsh (uncredited) Kathryn Rawson as Capitol Secretary (uncredited) Danielle Rene as Third Women (uncredited)