Ashton Kutcher as Evan Melora Walters as Andrea Amy Smart as Kayleigh Elden Henson as Lenny William Lee Scott as Tommy John Patrick Amedori as Evan at 13 Irene Gorovaia as Kayleigh at 13 Kevin G. Schmidt as Lenny at 13 Jesse James as Tommy at 13 Logan Lerman as Evan at 7 Sarah Widdows as Kayleigh at 7 Jake Kaese as Lenny at 7 Cameron Bright as Tommy at 7 Eric Stoltz as Mr. Miller Callum Keith Rennie as Jason Lorena Gale as Mrs. Boswell Nathaniel DeVeaux as Dr. Redfield (as Nathaniel Deveaux) John Tierney as Priest Kendall Cross as Mrs. Kagan Ted Friend as Anchor John B. Lowe as Professor Carter Ethan Suplee as Thumper Camille Sullivan as Cricket Tara Wilson as Heidi Jesse Hutch as Spencer Jacqueline Stewart as Gwen (as Jacqueline J. Stewart) Grant Thompson as Hunter Sadie Lawrence as Mrs. Halpern Bill Croft as Boss Glenn Richards as Pinching Customer Sam Easton as Theta Chi Pledge Daniel Spink as Senior Brother Douglas Arthurs as Karl (as Douglas H. Arthurs) Kevin Durand as Carlos Paul Lazenby as Rick June B. Wilde as Waitress Kimani Ray Smith as Orderly (as Kimani Smith) Trevor Jones as Sunnyvale Guard Colby Chartrand as Teen Punk Shelly Schiavoni as Mrs. Miller Brandy Kopp as Kristen (as Brandy Heidrick) Chapelle Jaffe as Madame Helga Scott Swanson as Obstetrician Kevan Ohtsji as Anesthesiologist Meilani Paul as Gesela (as Melanie Hall) Amy Esterle as Gothic Co-Ed David Cook as Moviegoer Magda Apanowicz as Teen Punk Girl Garry Little as Wedding Priest (as Gary Little) J. Jackson Kocela as Evan at 3 Andrew Olcott as Andrea's New Husband Riddle the Dog as Crockett the Dog Stan Edmonds as Crying Mental Patient (uncredited) Cameron K. Smith as Theater Patron (uncredited)