Billy Bob Thornton as Charles Farmer Virginia Madsen as Audrey 'Audie' Farmer Max Thieriot as Shepard Farmer Jasper Polish as Stanley Farmer Logan Polish as Sunshine Farmer Bruce Dern as Hal Mark Polish as FBI Agent Mathis Jon Gries as FBI Agent Killbourne Tim Blake Nelson as Kevin Munchak Sal Lopez as Pepe Garcia J.K. Simmons as Jacobson Kiersten Warren as Phyllis Rick Overton as Arnold 'Arnie' Millard Richard Edson as Chopper Miller Elise Eberle as Madison Roberts