Daveigh Chase as Samantha Briana Evigan as Corey James Lafferty as Iraq Jack Ed Westwick as Randy Walter Platz as Frank John Hawkes as Phil Bret Roberts as Officer O'Dell Jackson Rathbone as Jeremy Elizabeth Berkley as Trudy Barbara Tarbuck as Agatha Matthew Davis as Pastor John Nathan Stevens as Jeff Ryan Templeman as Mike Zulay Henao as Baelyn JJ Neward as Co-Worker (as J.J. Neward)