Jay Chandrasekhar as Zach Kevin Heffernan as Grogan Steve Lemme as Felix Bean Paul Soter as Matt Erik Stolhanske as Freaky Reaky Zach Chapman as Greg / WCOB Deejay Alison Bower as Emily (as Alison Clapp) Kayren Butler as Suzanne Arik Treston as Bailiff (as Arik Ben Treston) Jamison Selby as Traci Shannon Charles Lloyd as Officer Reese Leanne Cummings as Woman Jogger Sally Brackett as Cup Dropper James P.Q. Sperber as Pasta Fagioli Patrick R. Heffernan as Lamb Chop / Rugby Player #4 Michael Yurchak as Waiter David A. Puner as Math Guy Susan Clarke as Rois Rane Charlene English as Superperson Francesca Olivieri as Rimmy Rolson Laura Satzman as Sara Laura Arieh as Jennifer Montgomery Mia Persson as Marjorie Fontaine Jay Ward as Poet Laura Losada as Open Mic Emcee Jane Heffernan as Cafeteria Marjorie Reid Freeman as 50's Guy Kaitlyn E. Lynch as Julie The Bitter Poet as Prosecutor Philip X. Chapman as Dean Hedgepeth Michael Heffernan as Alternate Lawyer John Coen as Jug Bartender Dan Fey as Rugby Player #1 Ernie Enzien as Rugby Player #2 Tim Bluto as Rugby Player #3 Ted Griffin as Rick Johnson Mark Alter as Dominco John Ardolino as Dan Fey Melanie Skehar as Ursula (as Melanya Skehar) Rick Johnson as Peck Rugby Coach Tom Dubreuil as Referee Dusty Brown as Officer #1 Michael Lamb as Officer #2 K.C. Stewart as Officer #3 Phil Haney as Rugby Fan (uncredited)