John Krasinski as Carter Rutherford David de Vries as Princeton Reporter #1 (as David DeVries) Rick Forrester as Princeton Reporter #2 Craig S. Harper as Princeton Reporter #3 (as Craig Harper) George Clooney as Jimmy 'Dodge' Connelly Malcolm Goodwin as Bakes Matt Bushell as Curly Tommy Hinkley as Hardleg Tim Griffin as Ralph Robert Baker as Stump Nick Paonessa as Zoom Lance Barber as Toledo Referee Wayne Duvall as Coach Frank Ferguson Nicholas Bourdages as Bug Jason Drago as Toledo Player Bill Roberson as Mr. Dunn Hi Bedford-Roberson as Mrs. Dunn Stephen Root as Suds Renée Zellweger as Lexie Littleton Mark Teich as Joe Christian Stolte as Pete Jack Thompson as Harvey Max Casella as Lt. Mack Steiner Windy Wenderlich as Conductor Keith Loneker as Big Gus Schiller Marian Seldes as Clerk Thomas Murphy as Cook JD Cullum as Leonard (as J.D. Cullum) Jonathan Pryce as C.C. Frazier Randy Farmer as Foreman (as Randy H. Farmer) George Nannarello as Duluth Reporter #1 Dave Hager as Duluth Reporter #2 Danny Vinson as Duluth Reporter #3 Tom Glynn as Newspaper Man Mike O'Malley as Mickey Dylan Kussman as Soldier Frank Ryan Shively as Corporal Jack Kyle Nudo as German Soldier Tom Huff as Writer / Photographer Heather Goldenhersh as Belinda / Flapper Michael Roy Scott as Athletic Club Trainer (as Michael Scott) J. Todd Anderson as Man in Pool Ron Clinton Smith as Bouncer Ledisi Young as Blues Singer Christian Scott as Band / Horn Player Marcus Gilmore as Band / Drummer Mert Hatfield as Mayor David Bryant as Band / Piano Luques Curtis as Band / Bass Dan John Miller as Desk Clerk Scott Reynolds as Police Sergeant John Vance as Suicidal Man / Mother of Suicidal Man John McConnell as Bullhorn Fireman (as John 'Spud' McConnell) Peter Gerety as Commisioner Pete Harkin Robert Hy Gorman as Speakeasy Soldier #1 (as Rob Gorman) Ted Huckabee as Speakeasy Soldier #2 Jeremy Ratchford as Eddie Randy Newman as Piano Player Sharlene Thomas as Secretary Grant Heslov as Saul Keller Craig A. Meyer as Chicago Reporter Blake Clark as Chicago Referee Patt Noday as Chicago Radio Announcer David Pasquesi as Voiceover Announcer #1 Nick Toth as Voiceover Announcer #2 Richard Arboscello as Game Official (uncredited) Mellie Boozer as Flapper (uncredited) Don Calhoun as Newspaper Man / Fan (uncredited) (unconfirmed) Jerry Cashman as Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) Richard Gaither as Press (uncredited) Anthony Garner as Pressbox Reporter (uncredited) Ray Hammack as Game Official (uncredited) Christy Johnson as Chicago Teamer (uncredited) Ted Johnson as Commissioner (uncredited) Andrew R. Kaplan as Sideline Photographer / Fan (uncredited) Stephen Kay as Chicago Bartender (uncredited) Zack Kay as Bulldogs #13 (uncredited) Jim Keisler as Duluth Bulldogs Trainer (uncredited) Dan A. R. Kelly as Chicago Fan (uncredited) Ray Kendrick as Dining Car Guest (uncredited) RJ Konner as Employment Officer (uncredited) Steve McClure as Game Official (uncredited) Trey Moore as Chicago Teamer (uncredited) W. Scott Parker III as Commissioner von Manstein (uncredited) John Rutland as Speakeasy patron (uncredited) Stefan Schuette as Bar Patron (uncredited) Tommy Scott as Reporter (uncredited) Ryan Sloth as Football Player / Toledo #5 / Dayton #37 (uncredited) Ron Stafford as Reporter (uncredited) William Stine as Chicago Reporter (uncredited)