Elena Anaya as Sofia Buñuel Adam Brody as Carter Webb Kelsey Keel as Teenage Girl #1 Danielle Savre as Teenage Girl #2 Gia Mantegna as Teenage Girl #3 (as Gina Mantegna) Rob Reinis as Avi Rosenberg JoBeth Williams as Agnes Webb Makenzie Vega as Paige Hardwicke Kristen Stewart as Lucy Hardwicke Meg Ryan as Sarah Hardwicke Olympia Dukakis as Phyllis Dustin Milligan as Eric Watts Graham Wardle as Gabe Foley Elise Gatien as Tiffany Christine Danielle as Tanya Clark Gregg as Nelson Hardwicke Jeff Cunningham as Howard Portchnik Tamara Lovegrove as Party Girl #1 Brittany Starling as Party Girl #2 Ilyse Mimoun as Nelson's Assistant Karin Konoval as Dr. Ida Rosen Ginnifer Goodwin as Janey Angus as Bozo Beau Mirchoff as Teenager (uncredited)