John Lithgow as Malcolm / Robert Stockman Jon Tenney as Helicopter Pilot Ryan Phillippe as Harlan Dykstra Hank Azaria as Carter Billy Bob Thornton as Jack Marsden Kelly Lynch as Lucy Jon Bon Jovi as Danny Kleoka Renee Sands as 4-Year-Old Girl Matt Ross as Ben Hickson Judge Reinhold as Policeman Leigh French as Waitress Christopher Dalton as Old Farmer Jamie Lee Curtis as Sierra Kahan Tiffany Paulsen as Heather the Stockbreeder Jeanette H. Wilson as White Haired Woman Matthew Winter as Shine Kahan Jake Gyllenhaal as Jake / Blue Kahan Michelle Bonilla as Nurse Matt Clark as Sheriff Stanley Kroopf Maggie Gyllenhaal as Christina the Babysitter Ramsay Midwood as Bill the Gas Station Guy Milo Plasil as Mafia Enforcer Ted Danson as Gianni Saletzzo Daniel Alonso as Thug Holding Dog Tom Burke as Straight Man Seamus McNally as Hippie (as Seamus McNally Jr.) Joe McCrackin as Cowboy Paul Prendergast as 25-Year-Old Man J. Neil Bloomer as Crowd Scene Hippie (uncredited) Steve Carell as Party Extra with Funny Pants (uncredited) Ungenita Prevost as 4-Year-Old Girl's Mother (uncredited)