Greg Kinnear as Frank Herlihy Jordan Carlos as Young Husband Dequina Moore as Young Wife Joseph Badalucco Jr. as Accident Bystander #1 (as Joe Badalucco) Brian Hutchison as Accident Bystander #2 Tyree Michael Simpson as Sneezy Cop (as Tyre Simpson) Julia K. Murney as Sneezy Lady Ricky Gervais as Bertram Pincus D.D.S. Claire Lautier as Upper East Side Lady Aasif Mandvi as Dr. Prashar Bridget Moloney as Receptionist Raymond J. Lee as Greenpeace Guy (as Raymond Lee) Joey Mazzarino as Food Delivery Guy Brad Oscar as Day Doorman Kathleen Landis as Resident