Angelina Jolie as Christine Collins Gattlin Griffith as Walter Collins Michelle Gunn as Sandy Michael Kelly as Detective Lester Ybarra Jan Devereaux as Operator Erica Grant as Operator Antonia Bennett as Operator Kerri Randles as Operator Frank Wood as Ben Harris Morgan Eastwood as Girl on Tricycle Madison Hodges as Neighborhood Girl John Malkovich as Rev. Gustav Briegleb Colm Feore as Chief James E. Davis Devon Conti as Arthur Hutchins Ric Sarabia as Man at Diner