David Schwimmer as Charlie Simon Pegg as Gus Alice Eve as Josie McBroom Jon Polito as Agent Hymes Natascha McElhone as Penelope Wood Mimi Rogers as Mrs. Smalls Billy Asher as Deputy Garman Julian Glover as 80 year old Blind Man Olivia Peterson as Emily Sarah Edmondson as Isabella Amber Sealey as Call Center Supervisor Shauna Shim as Melanie 1 Laurence Bouvard as Melanie 2 Mindy Lee Raskin as Melanie 3 Kenneth Jay as Barman