John Cusack as Craig Schwartz Cameron Diaz as Lotte Schwartz Ned Bellamy as Derek Mantini Eric Weinstein as Father at Puppet Show Madison Lanc as Daughter at Puppet Show Octavia Spencer as Woman in Elevator (as Octavia L. Spencer) Mary Kay Place as Floris Orson Bean as Dr. Lester Catherine Keener as Maxine Lund K.K. Dodds as Wendy Reginald C. Hayes as Don (as Reggie Hayes) Byrne Piven as Captain Mertin Judith Wetzell as Tiny Woman John Malkovich as John Horatio Malkovich Kevin Carroll as Cab Driver Willie Garson as Guy in Restaurant W. Earl Brown as First J.M. Inc. Customer Charlie Sheen as Charlie Gerald Emerick as Sad Man in Line Bill M. Ryusaki as Mr. Hiroshi Carlos Jacott as Larry the Agent Richard Fancy as Johnson Heyward Patti Tippo as Malkovich's Mother Daniel Hansen as Boy Malkovich Gregory Sporleder as Drunk at Bar Mariah O'Brien as Girl Creeped Out by Malkovich Kelly Teacher as Emily Jacqueline Benoît as Lester's Friend (as Jacqueline Benoit) William Buck as Lester's Friend (as William N. Buck) Christine D. Coleman as Lester's Friend Jeanne Diehl as Lester's Friend Audrey Gelfund as Lester's Friend (as Audrey Gelfand) Yetta Ginsburg as Lester's Friend Sylvester Jenkins as Lester's Friend Roy C. Johnson as Lester's Friend Eddie J. Low as Lester's Friend Ralph W. Spaulding as Lester's Friend David Wyler as Lester's Friend Flori Wyler as Lester's Friend Kevin Lee as Ballet Dancer Marlowe Bassett as Ballet Dancer Jennifer Canzoneri as Ballet Dancer Kristie Cordle as Ballet Dancer Denise Dabrowski as Ballet Dancer Kristin Condon as Ballet Dancer (as Kristin D'Andrea) Charlene Grimsley as Ballet Dancer Christine Krejer as Ballet Dancer Erica Long as Ballet Dancer Yvonne Montelius as Ballet Dancer Jessica Neuberger as Ballet Dancer Sara Rifkin as Ballet Dancer Elizabeth Rivera as Ballet Dancer Chelsa Sjostrom as Ballet Dancer Pamela Hayden as Featured Character Voice (voice) Jayne Hess as Featured Character Voice (voice) Michelle Madden as Featured Character Voice (voice) Greg O'Neill as Featured Character Voice (voice) Neil Ross as Featured Character Voice (voice) Bill Wittman as Featured Character Voice (voice) Lance Bangs as Locker Room Bully (uncredited) Kacee DeMasi as Cab Driver (uncredited) Andy Dick as Himself (archive footage) (uncredited) Eddie L. Fauria as Bartender (uncredited) David Fincher as Christopher Bing (uncredited) Jester Hairston as Lester's Friend (uncredited) Isaac Hanson as Himself at Awards Ceremony (archive footage) (uncredited) Taylor Hanson as Himself (archive footage) (uncredited) Zac Hanson as Himself (archive footage) (uncredited) Dustin Hoffman as Willy Loman (archive footage) (uncredited) Victor Isaac as Student (uncredited) Spike Jonze as Derek Mantini's Assistant for Emily Dickinson Puppet (uncredited) James Murray as Student Puppeteer (uncredited) Sean Penn as Himself (uncredited) Brad Pitt as Himself (uncredited) Winona Ryder as Herself (archive footage) (uncredited) Gary Sinise as Stage Role (archive footage) (uncredited) Trevor Lawrence Young as Mr. Malkovich Sr. (uncredited)