Chris Ambrose as Superman Joey Krajcar as Batman Josh Hutcherson as Robin Cameron Carter as Green Lantern Daniel Tay as Young Harvey Mary Faktor as Housewife Paul Giamatti as Harvey Pekar Harvey Pekar as Real Harvey Shari Springer Berman as Interviewer (voice) Larry John Meyers as Throat Doctor (as Larry John Myers) Vivienne Benesch as Lana Barbara Brown as Nurse Earl Billings as Mr. Boats Danny Hoch as Marty James Urbaniak as Robert Crumb Eli Ganias as Pahls Sylvia Kauders as Old Jewish Lady Rebecca Borger as Cashier Nick Baxter as Mattress Guy #1 Allen Branstein as Mattress Guy #2 Dick Prochaska as WW II Patient Charles Eduardos as Doctor Judah Friedlander as Toby Radloff Robert Pulcini as Bob The Director Toby Radloff as Real Toby Bianca Santos as Counter Girl Maggie Moore as Alice Quinn Hope Davis as Joyce Brabner Mike Rad as Rand Amy K. Harmon as Cheery Waitress Joyce Brabner as Real Joyce Donal Logue as Stage Actor Harvey Molly Shannon as Stage Actor Joyce Eytan Mirsky as Guitarist Rob Grader as Stage Manager Terrence Sullivan as Letterman Regular Ebon Moss-Bachrach as MTV Director Patrick Lafferty as Yuppie Jesse Perez as Miguel Jeff Peters as Talk Show Host Ola Creston as PA #1 Robert J. Williams as Cancer Doctor James McCaffrey as Fred Madylin Sweeten as Danielle Danielle Batone as Real Danielle Jason Stevens as Letterman Regular Voice (voice) Todd Cummings as Talk Show Host Voice (voice) Rae Sunshine Lee as Cashier (uncredited) Marcus Wynnycky as Comic Book Fan (uncredited)