Daniel Day-Lewis as Daniel Plainview Martin Stringer as Silver Assay Worker Matthew Braden Stringer as Silver Assay Worker Jacob Stringer as Silver Assay Worker Joseph Mussey as Silver Assay Worker Barry Del Sherman as H.B. Ailman Harrison Taylor as Baby H.W. Plainview Stockton Taylor as Baby H.W. Plainview Paul F. Tompkins as Prescott Dillon Freasier as Young H.W. Plainview Kevin Breznahan as Signal Hill Man Jim Meskimen as Signal Hill Married Man Erica Sullivan as Signal Hill Woman Randall Carver as Mr. Bankside Coco Leigh as Mrs. Bankside Paul Dano as Paul Sunday Ciarán Hinds as Fletcher Sydney McCallister as Young Mary Sunday David Willis as Abel Sunday Christine Olejniczak as Mother Sunday Kellie Hill as Ruth Sunday James Downey as Al Rose Dan Swallow as Gene Blaize Robert Arber as Charlie Wrightsman Bob Bell as Geologist David Williams as Ben Blaut Joy Rawls as Eli Follower Louise Gregg as Eli Follower Amber Roberts as Eli Follower John W. Watts as Oil Worker Robert Caroline as Oil Worker Barry Bruce as Oil Worker Irene G. Hunter as Mrs. Hunter Hope Elizabeth Reeves as Elizabeth John Chitwood as Little Boston Doctor Kevin J. O'Connor as Henry David Warshofsky as H.M. Tilford Tom Doyle as J.J. Carter Colton Woodward as William Bandy John Burton as L.P. Clair Hans Howes as Mr. Bandy Robert Barge as Bartender Ronald Krut as Standard Oil Man Huey Rhudy as Standard Oil Man Steven Barr as Standard Oil Man Robert Hills as H.W. Plainview's Interpreter Colleen Foy as Adult Mary Sunday Russell Harvard as Adult H.W. Plainview Bob Bock as Priest (as Reverend Bob Bock) Vince Froio as Plainview Servant Phil Shelly as Plainview Servant Mary Elizabeth Barrett as Fanny Clark Misha Bugaev as Young man (uncredited) Brad Carr as Signal Hill Man Rhonda Reeves as Elizabeth's Mother (uncredited) Arne Starr as Signal Hill Resident (uncredited)