Richard Jenkins as Prof. Walter Vale Haaz Sleiman as Tarek Khalil Danai Jekesai Gurira as Zainab Hiam Abbass as Mouna Khalil Marian Seldes as Barbara Maggie Moore as Karen Michael Cumpsty as Charles Bill McHenry as Darin Richard Kind as Jacob Tzahi Moskovitz as Zev Amir Arison as Mr. Shah Neal Lerner as Martin Revere Ramon Fernandez as Cop #1 Frank Pando as Cop #2 Waleed Zuaiter as Omar Deborah Rush as Upper Eastside Woman Ashley Springer as Student Laith Nakli as Nasim Jacqueline Brogan as Waiter Walter Mudu as Ronald Cole (as Walter T. Mudu) Yevgeniy Dekhtyar as Slavic Man Earl Baker Jr. as Lester James Walter the Dog as Sprinkles the Dog Bandar Albuliwi as Man in subway (uncredited) Michael Bennett as Conference Attendee (uncredited) Brother Eden Douglas as Airport Security Guard (uncredited) Jesus A. Del Rosario Jr. as Park Drummer (uncredited)