Jon Foster as Art Bechstein Peter Sarsgaard as Cleveland Arning Sienna Miller as Jane Bellwether Nick Nolte as Joe Bechstein Mena Suvari as Phlox Lombardi Omid Abtahi as Mohammed Keith Michael Gregory as Keith Don Wadsworth as Class Instructor Christian Hand as Punk Rock Bathroom Patron Jarid Faubel as Mohawk Man Tim Hartman as Restaurant Manager Seth Adams as Feldman Jocelyn Wrzosek as Townie Patrick Jordan as Phlox's New Boyfriend Stephen Liska as Jimmy Breezy