Louise Fletcher as Miz Elda Henry Thomas as Man of God Liana Liberato as Cadi Forbes Soren Fulton as Fagan Kai A.J. Buckley as Angor Forbes Stewart Finlay-McLennan as Brogan Kai Peter Wingfield as The Sin Eater Elizabeth Lackey as Fia Forbes Thea Rose as Lilybet Kim Myers as Iona Kai Gabrielle Fitzpatrick as Bletsung McLeod Valerie Wildman as Gervase O'Dara Anne Cullimore Decker as Granny Forbes Michael Flynn as Laochailand Kai Molly Jepson as Elen Forbes Nick Praggastis as Cleet Kai Parker Hadley as Cullen Stefania Barr as Glynnis Dee Macaluso as Elderly Woman (voice) Don Shanks as Indian Chief Morgan B. Ackerman as Young Bletsung McLeod Blaze Call as Young Brogan Christine Elder as Young Miz Elda Denali McKinney as Young Gervaise Laron Wilson as Wounded Indian Josh McLerran as Settler (uncredited)