Jeremy Piven as Don Ready Ving Rhames as Jibby Newsome James Brolin as Ben Selleck David Koechner as Brent Gage Kathryn Hahn as Babs Merrick Ed Helms as Paxton Harding Jordana Spiro as Ivy Selleck Tony Hale as Wade Zooha Ken Jeong as Teddy Dang Rob Riggle as Peter Selleck Alan Thicke as Stu Harding Charles Napier as Dick Lewiston Jonathan Sadowski as Blake Noureen DeWulf as Heather Wendie Malick as Tammy Selleck