Amber Tamblyn as Tibby Tomko-Rollins Alexis Bledel as Lena Kaligaris America Ferrera as Carmen Lowell Blake Lively as Bridget Vreeland Rachel Nichols as Julia Tom Wisdom as Ian Rachel Ticotin as Carmen's Mom Leonardo Nam as Brian McBrian Michael Rady as Kostas Shohreh Aghdashloo as Professor Nasrin Mehani Blythe Danner as Greta Jesse Williams as Leo Lucy Hale as Effie Kaligaris (as Lucy Kate Hale) Maria Konstadarou as Yia Yia Ernie Lively as Bridget's Father Stevie Ray Dallimore as Nigel O'Bannon Alison Folland as Stage Manager Margaret Zacharoula Klimatsaki as Melia Nastas Ippokratis as Priest Panagiotis Pitsilos as Old Fisherman Nathaniel Martello-White as Dig Site Student Ray Emmanuel Leconte as Dig Site Student Miles Stavros Parisis as Nasrin's Husband Danae Savva as Nasrin's Daughter Maryann Urbano as Art Teacher Annika (as Maryanne Urbano) Paul Coughlan as Carmen's Stepdad Rebekah Aramini as Lena's Mom Cory Nichols as Nicky Rollins Carly Rose Sonenclar as Kathryn Rollins Erik Jensen as Video Store Manager Phi Adrienne Bailon as Cute Video Couple Girl Cannon Smith as Cute Video Store Couple Guy Dylan Sheridan as Male Video Store Customer Lindsay Michelle Nader as Female Video Store Customer Crystal McCrary Anthony as Mom with Screaming Kids Nicole Patrick as Apprentice #1 Josh Caras as Apprentice Actor #2 (as Josh Barclay Caras) Kiely Williams as Yaffa Waitress Max Woertendyke as Yale Stagehand Victor Slezak as Doctor Marceline Hugot as Nurse Bill Corsair as Old Shepherd Kyle MacLachlan as Bill Kerr Samantha Safdie as Teenage Female Couple Jack Sneed as Apprentice Peter Conboy as Anniversary guest (uncredited) Jay Ferraro as Theater Patron (uncredited) Marty Garcia as Theatre goer (uncredited) Karmen Kluge as Lady in Waiting (uncredited) Kimberly Magness as Audience (uncredited) Sean Marrinan as Theatre goer (uncredited) Rich Rothbell as Yoga Man (uncredited) Harry L. Seddon as Tibby's Dad (uncredited) Ken Sladyk as Theater Patron (uncredited) Conor Timmis as Theater Goer (uncredited)