James Roday as Dick Murphy Sam Huntington as Dinkadoo Murphy Jay Paulson as Dave Murphy Charlie Finn as Kevin Haub Ryan McDow as Hunter Bullette Rip Torn as Oldman Keegan Olmstead as Young Dinkadoo Lew Temple as Bill C.K. McFarland as State Trooper (as CK McFarland) Rachel Klein as Blush Hillary Higgins as Honey Lisa Marie Newmyer as Satin Matt Bardocz as Hefty Passenger (as Matthew C. Bardocz) Brad Leland as Dot the Waitress Louanne Stephens as Lady Customer Elizabeth Chambers as Freshman Co-Ed Kelly Bright as Senior Co-Ed Ed Geldart as Farmer / Elderly Farmer / Grandpa J.D. Evermore as Angry Motorcycle Cop Joey Basham as Little Dick Chris Warner as Motorcycle Cop Bonnie Gallup as Grandma Max Nowak as Young Kevin Mia Zottoli as Cheyenne Kristen Growcock as Becky Josh Painting as Gardner "Fatty" Johnny Bartee as Cafe Customer (uncredited) Ryan Thomas Brockington as Joey (uncredited) Thomas Haden Church as Agent Madsen / Trooper (uncredited) Susan E. Denison as Sorority Girl (uncredited) Greg Dorchak as Jimmy (uncredited) David Scott Heck as 60's Stoner (uncredited) Kevin Pollak as Agent Brinkley (uncredited) Brent Smiga as Pothead Driver (uncredited) Tony Vespe as Taunting Boy (uncredited) Tennille Williams as Sorority Girl (uncredited)