Joaquin Phoenix as Ethan Learner Elle Fanning as Emma Jennifer Connelly as Grace Learner Sean Curley as Josh Samuel Ryan Finn as Cello Player Eddie Alderson as Lucas Mark Ruffalo as Dwight Arno Susan Powell as Elegant Parent Cordell Clyde as Jimmy McBride Antoni Corone as Sergeant Burke Kevin Herbst as Driving Trooper Mira Sorvino as Ruth Wheldon Gary Kohn as Norris Wheldon John Slattery as Steve Cutter Nora Ferrari as Nora Fannelli Linda Dano as Grandmother John Rothman as Minister Geisha Otero as Blanca Brett Haley as Brett Sinead Daly as American Girl Armin Amiri as Rashid Johnathan Tchaikovsky as Jock (as Johnny Tchaikovsky) Lee Goffin-Bonenfant as Student Americk Lewis as African American Student Danny Johnson as Investigating Trooper Bill Camp as Desk Trooper Stephanie Weyman as Cheryl Raum-Aron as Gerry Debra Robinson as Parent Michael Anzalone as Dwight's Neighbor David Anzuelo as Raul Julián Rebolledo as News Announcer (voice) Peter Pamela Rose as News Announcer (voice) Kathryn Markey as News Announcer (voice) Ross Klavan as News Announcer (voice) (as Ross Klaven) Sean Oliver as Podcast (voice) Blanca Camacho as Podcast (voice) Jason Harris as Podcast (voice) Dennis Albanese as Father (uncredited) Mary Kate Malat as Child in Recital (uncredited) Robert Nardi as Amusement Park Parent (uncredited)