Kevin Costner as Mr. Earl Brooks Demi Moore as Det. Tracy Atwood Dane Cook as Mr. Smith William Hurt as Marshall Marg Helgenberger as Emma Brooks Ruben Santiago-Hudson as Hawkins Danielle Panabaker as Jane Brooks Aisha Hinds as Nancy Hart Lindsay Crouse as Captain Lister Jason Lewis as Jesse Vialo Reiko Aylesworth as Sheila - Jesse's Lawyer Matt Schulze as Thorton Meeks Yasmine Delawari as Sunday Traci Dinwiddie as Sarah Leaves Michael Cole as Atwoods Lawyer Jim Farnum as Master of Ceremonies Megan Brown as Dance Couple (Woman) Ross Francis as Dance Couple (Man) Kit Gwin as Detective Carfagno Marcus Hester as Detective Smolny Jamie McShane as Crime Lab Technician Laura Bailey as Flight Attendant Jon Paul Burkhart as Flight Attendant Matthew Posey as AA Leader Brandon Olive as Summons Server Rosie Cafarelli as Vaughn Ben Glass as ER Doctor Kanin Howell as Pick-Up Driver Steve Coulter as Roger Stephen Michael Ayers as Mr. Clifford Mark Scarboro as Detective Brad Evans as Cop (as Brad L. Evans) David Gibbons as Box Plant Manager Jasa Abreo as On Plane Flight Attendant Rommel Sulit as Japanese Client Phillip DeVona as Police Officer Chuck Halley as Banquet Guest (uncredited) Colvin Roberson as Driver (uncredited) Van White as Police Officer Steven E. Williams as Motorist (uncredited)