Jason Biggs as Tom Willoman Eva Longoria Parker as Rebecca Seabrook Rob Corddry as Harper Billings Ryan Newman as Carlotta Monica Potter as Laura Buchwald Will Sasso as Jesse Buchwald Zachary Gordon as Frankie Fowler Nat Faxon as Turner Abernathy Hayes MacArthur as Digdug O'Shannassy Jill Latiano as Nurse Gretchen Matt Walsh as Mr. Conroy Nathan Wesdell as Otis Allen Alvarado as Miguel Jarrod Bailey as Dickers Miranda Bailey as Melody Patricia Belcher as Colette Juan Carlos Cantu as Alejandro Ethynn Tanner Cerney as Asbestos Kid Michael Cheyovich as Coco Jack Donner as Old Curt Timothy Dowling as Robber (as Tim Dowling) Johnny Drocco as Flunky Kyle Gass as Decatur Doublewide Gigi Goff as Mernay Brenda Goodbread as Lunch Lady Geoffrey Gould as Grandfather Abernathy's friend Logan Grove as Nickelby Maya Harvey as Child Secretary Maxine Hayden as Teacher Ed Helms as Maurice James Howarth as Flunky 2 Nadji Jeter as Sling Shot Kid Chris Kerner as Homecoming King Grant Klemann as Zippy Patrick Manuel as Sling Shot Kid Sandy Martin as Olympia Parpadelle Miranda May as Sheila Dannika Northcott as Adelle Luca Oriel as Marcos Erik Palladino as Smooth Bob Willoman Alejandro Patino as Helado Andy Pessoa as Walter Christian Pikes as Bartlett Jonathan Rackman as Music Teacher Nicholas Roget-King as Basil Darius Rose as AJ Ethan Scheid as Asbestos kid Zach Selwyn as Singing Teacher Uriah Shelton as Prep School Kid Kiernan Shipka as Sarah Kaliya Skye as Smelly Alice Anthony Tavera as Rinaldo Bryan James Taylor as Tennesse Student Servant David Weiss as Young Tom Jim Cody Williams as Curse Man