Abigail Breslin as Olive Hoover Greg Kinnear as Richard Hoover Paul Dano as Dwayne Alan Arkin as Grandpa Edwin Hoover Toni Collette as Sheryl Hoover Steve Carell as Frank Ginsberg Marc Turtletaub as Doctor #1 Jill Talley as Cindy Brenda Canela as Diner Waitress Julio Oscar Mechoso as Mechanic Chuck Loring as Convenience Store Proprietor Justin Shilton as Josh Gordon Thomson as Larry Sugarman Steven Christopher Parker as Teen Boy #1 Bryan Cranston as Stan Grossman John Walcutt as Doctor #2 Paula Newsome as Linda Dean Norris as State Trooper McCleary Beth Grant as Pageant Official Jenkins Wallace Langham as Kirby Lauren Shiohama as Miss California Mary Lynn Rajskub as Pageant Assistant Pam Jerry Giles as Funeral Home Worker Geoff Meed as Biker Dad Matt Winston as Pageant MC Joan Scheckel as Judge Casandra Ashe as Girl in Hallway Mel Rodriguez as Officer Martinez Alexandria Alaman as Pageant Contestant Alissa Anderegg as Pageant Contestant Brittany Baird as Pageant Contestant Cambria Baird as Pageant Contestant Brenae Bandy as Pageant Contestant Kristen Holaas as Pageant Contestant Maliah Hudson as Pageant Contestant Destry Jacobs as Pageant Contestant Lindsey Jordan as Pageant Contestant Shane Murphy as Pageant Contestant Annabelle Roberts as Pageant Contestant Sydni Stevenson-Love as Pageant Contestant Nicole Stoehr as Pageant Contestant Lauren Yee as Pageant Contestant Erik David as Photographer (uncredited) Marc De'Antone as Seminar class (uncredited) Tara Dawn Holland as Herself (archive footage) (uncredited) Ksenia Jarova as Pretty Girl (uncredited) Robert O'Connor as Pageant Judge #1 (uncredited) Regis Philbin as Himself (voice) (uncredited) Matthew W. Tate as Funeral Worker #2 (uncredited)