Katherine Heigl as Holly Berenson Josh Duhamel as Eric Messer Josh Lucas as Sam Alexis Clagett as Sophie Brynn Clagett as Sophie Brooke Clagett as Sophie Hayes MacArthur as Peter Novak Christina Hendricks as Alison Novak Sarah Burns as Janine Groff Jessica St. Clair as Beth Brooke Liddell as Older Sophie Kiley Liddell as Older Sophie Britt Flatmo as Amy Rob Huebel as Ted Faizon Love as Cab Driver Melissa McCarthy as DeeDee DeRay Davis as Lonnie Kumail Nanjiani as Simon Andrew Daly as Scott Bill Brochtrup as Gary Will Sasso as Josh Majandra Delfino as Jenna Jason MacDonald as Cousin Tara Ochs as Cousin's Wife Wilbur Fitzgerald as Peter's Dad Melissa Ponzio as Victoria (Stripper Cousin) Reggie Lee as Alan Burke Markus Flanagan as Chef Phillipe Brooke Josephson as Liz Chanta Rivers as CPS Worker Eric Phillips as Stoned Teenager Andy Buckley as George Dunn L. Warren Young as Officer Young Johanna Jowett as Jill Jody Thompson as Worker Horace Toney as Court Clerk Millie Fairchild as Older Woman Rob Nagle as Neighbor Dad Katie Kneeland as Female Patron Patricia French as Judge Gorling Ron Clinton Smith as Contractor Antwan Mills as Airport Security Steve Nash as Himself Shayne Kohout as Pregnant Woman with Deedee Danielle L. Grant as Ticket Counter Lady Eddie Frierson as Sports Announcer (voice) Olivia Hayes as Madison Tim Blanchard as Wedding Party Guest (uncredited) Gregory Cook as Orderly (uncredited) Gilbert Galon as Hawks Fan (uncredited) Keith Allen Hayes as Attorney (uncredited) Barry Hopkins as Block Party Guest (uncredited) Jonathan Lewandowski Jaxson as Waiter (uncredited) Liz Kate as Evaluation Child (uncredited) Katie Kneeland as Female Patron (uncredited) Bella Marina Marcello as Neighborhood Child (uncredited) Marco Marcello as Carter / Neighborhood Child (uncredited) Molly Marler as (uncredited) Mista Martel as Hawks Fan (uncredited) Katherine Neslund as Grocery Shopper (uncredited) Elizabeth Pistolis as 1st Birthday Party Guest (uncredited) Eddie Rattanasouk as Traveler (uncredited) Shawn Reynolds as Grocery Shopper (uncredited) Alexis Renee Ruby as Middle School Student (uncredited) Sapphire as Neighborhood Party Attendee (uncredited) Gordon J. Shenkle as Control Room Operator 2 (uncredited) Liz Smallwood as Car Driver (uncredited) Jean Smart as Holly's Mother (uncredited) Gregory Marshall Smith as Control Room Tech (uncredited) Alexis Walters as Soccer Player (uncredited) Mark Wilson as Producer (uncredited)