Ryan Gosling as Lars Lindstrom Emily Mortimer as Karin Paul Schneider as Gus R.D. Reid as Reverend Bock Kelli Garner as Margo Nancy Beatty as Mrs. Gruner Doug Lennox as Mr. Hofstedtler Joe Bostick as Mr. Shaw Liz Gordon as Mrs. Schindler Nicky Guadagni as Mrs. Petersen Patricia Clarkson as Dagmar Karen Robinson as Cindy Maxwell McCabe-Lokos as Kurt Billy Parrott as Erik Sally Cahill as Deb Angela Vint as Sandy Liisa Repo-Martell as Laurel Boyd Banks as Russell Darren Hynes as Moose Víctor Gómez as Hector Tommy Chang as Nelson Arnold Pinnock as Baxter Joshua Peace as Jerry Aurora Browne as Lisa Alec McClure as Steve Tannis Burnett as Nurse Amy Lauren Ash as Holly Lindsey Connell as Victoria Aaron Ferguson as Choir Member #1 Danna Howe as Choir Member #2 Annabelle Torsein as Choir Member #3 Tim Blake as Choir Member #4 Torquil Colbo as Choir Member #5