Nicolas Cage as John Koestler Chandler Canterbury as Caleb Koestler Rose Byrne as Diana Wayland Lara Robinson as Abby Wayland / Lucinda Embry D.G. Maloney as The Stranger Nadia Townsend as Grace Koestler Alan Hopgood as Reverend Koestler Adrienne Pickering as Allison Koestler Joshua Long as Younger Caleb Danielle Carter as Miss Taylor (1959) Alethea McGrath as Miss Taylor (2009) David Lennie as Principal Clark (1959) Tamara Donnellan as Lucinda's Mother Travis Waite as Lucinda's Father Ben Mendelsohn as Phil Beckman