Ashton Kutcher as Spencer Aimes Katherine Heigl as Jen Kornfeldt Tom Selleck as Mr. Kornfeldt Catherine O'Hara as Mrs. Kornfeldt Katheryn Winnick as Vivian Kevin Sussman as Mac Bailey Lisa Ann Walter as Olivia Brooks Casey Wilson as Kristen Rob Riggle as Henry Martin Mull as Holbrook Alex Borstein as Lily Baily Usher Raymond as Kevin the Manager (as Usher Raymond IV) Letoya Luckett as Amanda (as LeToya Luckett) Michael Daniel Cassady as Milo Larry Joe Campbell as Pete Denham