Paul Rudd as Peter Klaven Rashida Jones as Zooey Rice Sarah Burns as Hailey Jason Segel as Sydney Fife Greg Levine as Hailey's Date Jaime Pressly as Denise Jon Favreau as Barry Jane Curtin as Joyce Klaven J.K. Simmons as Oswald Klaven Andy Samberg as Robbie Klaven Jean Villepique as Leanne (Davis Dunn Receptionist) Rob Huebel as Tevin Downey Kym Whitley as Female Co-Worker #1 Colleen Crabtree as Female Co-Worker #2 Caroline Farah as Female Co-Worker #3