Leonardo DiCaprio as Amsterdam Vallon Daniel Day-Lewis as Bill 'The Butcher' Cutting Cameron Diaz as Jenny Everdeane Jim Broadbent as William 'Boss' Tweed John C. Reilly as Happy Jack Mulraney Henry Thomas as Johnny Sirocco Liam Neeson as 'Priest' Vallon Brendan Gleeson as Walter 'Monk' McGinn Gary Lewis as McGloin Stephen Graham as Shang Eddie Marsan as Killoran Alec McCowen as Reverend Raleigh (as Alec Mccowen) David Hemmings as Mr. Schermerhorn Lawrence Gilliard Jr. as Jimmy Spoils (as Larry Gilliard Jr.) Cara Seymour as Hell-Cat Maggie Roger Ashton-Griffiths as P.T. Barnum Peter-Hugo Daly as One-Armed Priest (as Peter Hugo Daly) Cian McCormack as Young Amsterdam (as Cian Mccormack) Andrew Gallagher as Young Johnny Philip Kirk as O'Connell Guard Leader Rab Affleck as Plug Uglies Leader (as Rab Afleck) Bill Barclay as Shirt Tails Leader Nick Bartlett as Chichesters Leader Robert Goodman as Forty Thieves Leader Tim Pigott-Smith as Calvinist Minister Liam Carney as Bill The Butcher's Gang #1 Gary McCormack as Bill The Butcher's Gang #2 (as Gary Mccormack) David McBlain as Bill The Butcher's Gang #3 (as David Mcblain) Dick Holland as True Blue American Speaker Katherine Wallach as Jenny's Girl Carmen Hanlon as Jenny's Girl Ilaria D'Elia as Jenny's Girl Laurie Ventry as Resident Woman Ford Kiernan as Black Joke Chief Alec McMahon as Resident man Nevan Finegan as Dead Rabbit Gang Member (as Nevan Finnegan) Dominiquie Vandenberg as Dead Rabbit Gang Member (as Dominique Vandenberg) Sai-Kit Yung as Chinese at Sparrow's Pagoda (as Stuart Ong) Basil Chung as Elderly Chinese at Pagoda Finbar Furey as Satan's Circus Singer Sean Gilder as Rat Pit Game Master Richard Graham as Harvey - Card Player Richard Strange as Undertaker Douglas Plasse as Medical Student R. Bruce Steinheimer as Army Recruiter (as Bruce Steinheimer) David Bamber as Passenger on Omnibus Barbara Bouchet as Mrs. Schermerhorn Michael Byrne as Horace Greeley Lucy Davenport as Miss Schermerhorn Maura O'Connell as Street Singer Alex Howden as Assistant Hangman James Ramsay as Arthur - Condemned Man Iain McColl as Seamus - Condemned Man (as Iain Mccoll) Louie Brownsell as Legless Soldier Gennaro Condemi as She-He Kieran Hurley as Recruiter (as Kiernan Hurley) John Sessions as Harry Watkins - Lincoln Michael H. Billingsley as Uncle Tom Steven Blake as Mr. Shelby (as Steven C. Matthews) Giovanni Lombardo Radice as Mr. Legree Alexia Murray as Topsy (as Alexia J. Murray) Flaminia Fegarotti as Miss Eliza Bronco McLoughlin as Assassin (as Bronco Mcloughlin) Channing C. Holmes as Tap Dancer (as Channing Cook Holmes) Eliane Chappuis as Chinese Whore Roberta Quaresima as Whore #1 Marta Pilato as Whore #2 Jian Su as Chinese Acrobat Man Cao as Chinese General Kathy Shao-Lin Lee as Chinese Dancer Alexander Deng as Chinese Boy Singer Peter Berling as Knife Act Caller Patrick Gordon as Surgeon Brendan White as Archbishop Brendan Dempsey as Provost Marshal Registrar Taddeo Harbutt as Unruly Man Nazzareno Natale as Don Whiskerandos Colin Hill as Nativist Candidate Robert Linge as One-Armed Veteran Richard Syms as Drunken Repeater Christian Burgess as The Mayor Gerry Robert Byrne as Draft Official David Nicholls as O'Connell Guard Leader (as Dave Nicholls) Tim Faraday as Plug Uglies Leader Sean McGinley as Forty Thieves Leader (as Sean Mcginley) John Anthony Murphy as Kerryonians Leader Terry O'Neill as Chichesters Leader Vincent Pickering as American Guard Leader Nick Miles as Atlantic Guard Leader Ian Pirie as Slaughter Housers Leader John McGlynn as Bowery Boys Leader (as John Mcglynn) Larry Kaplan as Bloodied Bureaucrat Leo Burmester as Telegraph Operator #1 (voice) (as Leo Burmeister) Justin Brennan as Telegraph Operator #2 (voice) Brian Mallon as Telegraph Operator #3 (voice) Joseph P. Reidy as Police Chief (as Joseph Reidy) Joel Strachan as Telegraph Operator Bill Murdoch as Robber on Dock Angela Pleasence as Woman Accomplice (as Angela Pleasance) Iain Agnew as General Wool (as Ian Agnew) Michael Hausman as Gunboat Captain Bob Colletti as Soldier in Mist Salvatore Billa as Native (uncredited) Brennan Caitlin as Hot Corn Girl (uncredited) Trevor Cooper as Man in Tweed's Office (uncredited) Claudio Coreno as A student (uncredited) Blaise Corrigan as Riot Thug "There's a $300 Man..." (uncredited) Ottaviano Dell'Acqua as Bill The Butcher' s Gang #4 (uncredited) Luca Foggiano as Principal (uncredited) Raffaella Ponzo as Johnny's Girlfriend (uncredited) Martin Scorsese as Wealthy Homeowner (uncredited) Donald Stewart as Anatomist (uncredited) Vincenzo Tanassi as Fireman (uncredited) Massimo Vanni as Soldier (uncredited)