Jason Segel as Peter Bretter Kristen Bell as Sarah Marshall Mila Kunis as Rachel Jansen Russell Brand as Aldous Snow Bill Hader as Brian Bretter Liz Cackowski as Liz Bretter Maria Thayer as Wyoma Jack McBrayer as Darald Taylor Wily as Kemo Davon McDonald as Dwayne the Bartender Steve Landesberg as Dr. Rosenbaum Jonah Hill as Matthew the Waiter Paul Rudd as Chuck Kala Alexander as Greg Kalani Robb as Helpful Hawaiian Waiter Francesca DeBlanco as Hostess at Buffet Branscombe Richmond as Keoki Billy Bush as Himself William Baldwin as Detective Hunter Rush Jason Bateman as Animal Instincts Detective Peter Lewis as Suspect on 'Animal Instincts' (as Peter Gray Lewis) Trula M. Marcus as Lawyer on 'Crime Scene' (as Trula Marcus) Kirk Fox as Mixer June Diane Raphael as Ann at the Bar Ahna O'Reilly as Leslie Tanisha Harper as Model Carla Gallo as Gag Me Girl Murray Miller as Photographer Cynthia Lamontagne as Female Bartender Max Alexander as Big Dracula Head Kris Fitzgerald as Man Who Proposes Brittany Ross as Screaming Girlfriend Joe 'Kaleo' Kelii as Singer in Band Peter Salett as Keyboard Player Gedde Watanabe as Hotel Manager Allan Jeff Ho as Male Bar Patron Chaunnel Salmon as Female Bar Patron Mervyn Lilo as Fire Dancer Philip Matila as Luau Band Leader Danielle Prem as Hula Dancer #1 Tehina-Mai K. Mataele as Hula Dancer #2 Agnes Matila as Hula Dancer #3 Genny Wilson as Engaged Luau Woman Scott Francis Russell as Engaged Luau Man Kristen Wiig as Yoga Instructor Luis Accinelli as Mr. Lopez Carla Alapont as Spanish Sex Girl Carol Binion as Puppeteer Tim Blaney as Puppeteer Julianne Buescher as Puppeteer Leslie Carrara as Puppeteer (as Leslie Carrara-Rudolph) BJ Guyer as Puppeteer (as B.J. Guyer) Sean Cw Johnson as Puppeteer (as Sean Johnson) Scott Land as Puppeteer Michael Oosterom as Puppeteer Michelan Sisti as Puppeteer Kevin Carlson as Puppeteer Victor Yerrid as Puppeteer Drew Massey as Puppeteer Brian Tochi as Makani Massi Furlan as Bar Patron at Table Jean Huynh as Bar Patron Amanda MacLachlan as Cocktail Waitress (uncredited) Albert Miranda as Bar Patron Sam Puefua as Local boy (uncredited) Phillip Sanchez as Theater Group (uncredited) Channing Swift as Club patron (uncredited) Caroline Timm as Bar patron