Meryl Streep as Sister Aloysius Beauvier Philip Seymour Hoffman as Father Brendan Flynn Amy Adams as Sister James Viola Davis as Mrs. Miller Alice Drummond as Sister Veronica Audrie J. Neenan as Sister Raymond (as Audrie Neenan) Susan Blommaert as Mrs. Carson Carrie Preston as Christine Hurley John Costelloe as Warren Hurley Lloyd Clay Brown as Jimmy Hurley Joseph Foster as Donald Miller (as Joseph Foster II) Bridget Megan Clark as Noreen Horan Mike Roukis as William London Haklar Dezso as Zither Player Frank Shanley as Kevin Robert Ridgell as Organist Sarah Giovanniello as Choir Singer #1 Katie Shelnitz as Choir Singer #2 Aaron O'Neill as Choir Singer #3 Thomas J. Meehan as Choir Singer #4 Samantha Chadbourne as Choir Singer #5 Christina Angelina Celone as Choir Singer #6 Melissa Viezel as Choir Singer #7 Emily Swimmer as Choir Singer #8 Katelyn Snell as Choir Singer #9 Shayne Fischman as Choir Singer #10 Coby D. Moran as Choir Singer #11 Alannah Iacovano as Girl in Church Frank Dolce as Ralph Paulie Litt as Tommy Conroy Matthew Marvin as Raymond Philip Post as Sister James' Student #1 Thomas J. Kennedy as Sister James' Student #2 Thomas A. Varrone as Sister James' Student #3 Sabrina Costa as Sister James' Student #4 Samantha Buczek as Sister James' Student #5 Gabriella Renne DiMaria as Sister James' Student #6 Ariana Silvestro as Sister James' Student #7 Michele Ciago as Sister James' Student #8 Anna Lonczak as Sister James' Student #9 Brandy Panfili as Sister James' Student #10 Molly Chiffer as Sarah Lydia Jordan as Alice (as Lydia Grace Jordan) Suzanne Hevner as Mrs. Kean Helen Stenborg as Sister Teresa Tom Toner as Monsignor Benedict Michael Puzzo as Father Sherman Margery Beddow as Mrs. Shields Jack O'Connell as Mr. McGuinn Marylouise Burke as Mrs. Deakins Valda Setterfield as Parishioner George Aloi as Parishioner (uncredited) Timothy J. Cox as Parishoner (uncredited) Seth Donavan as Church Patron (uncredited) Amanda Marie Florian as Student (uncredited) Evan Lewis as Parishoner (uncredited) Steph Van Vlack as Church patron (uncredited)