Steve Carell as Dan Burns Juliette Binoche as Marie Dane Cook as Mitch Burns Alison Pill as Jane Burns Brittany Robertson as Cara Burns Marlene Lawston as Lilly Burns Dianne Wiest as Nana John Mahoney as Poppy Norbert Leo Butz as Clay Amy Ryan as Eileen Jessica Hecht as Amy Frank Wood as Howard Henry Miller as Will Ella Miller as Rachel Cameron 'C.J.' Adams as Elliott Jessica Lussier as Jessica Seth D'Antuono as Gus Margot Janson as Olivia Willa Cuthrell-Tuttleman as Bella Emily Blunt as Ruthie Draper Felipe Dieppa as Marty Barasco Matthew Morrison as Policeman Bernie McInerney as James Lamson Amy Landecker as Cindy Lamson Steve Mellor as Bookstore Clerk Pauline Gregory as Bowling Alley Manager Shana Carr as Suzanne Burns Nicole Morin as Jane - Age 13 Charlotte Davies as Cara - Age 11 Zoe Pauliks as Lilly - Age 4 (as Zoe Paulkis) Lucas Hedges as Lilly's Dance Partner Sondre Lerche as Himself Kato Ådland as Wedding Band (The Faces Down) - Guitar Ole Ludvig Krüger as Wedding Band (The Faces Down) - Drums Morten Skage as Wedding Band (The Faces Down) - Bass Marci Occhino as Wedding Singer Ellen Becker-Gray as Customer in Coffee Shoppe (uncredited) Kevin DeCoste as Wedding Guest (uncredited) Jaclyn Sabogal as Teen in bakery (uncredited) Melanie Scalera as Teen in cafe (uncredited)