Ryan Reynolds as Frank Allen Emily Mortimer as Susan Allen Stuart Townsend as Buddy Endrow Sarah Chalke as Paula Crowe Mike Erwin as Ed Constance Zimmer as Peg the Teacher Matreya Fedor as Jesse Allen (7 years) Elisabeth Harnois as Jesse Allen Chris William Martin as Damon Jovanna Huguet as Maid of Honor Christopher Jacot as Simon / Best Man Alessandro Juliani as Ken Lisa Calder as Sherri Ty Olsson as Evil Ferryman Jocelyne Loewen as Pregnant Nancy