Ben Affleck as Gavin Banek Samuel L. Jackson as Doyle Gipson Kim Staunton as Valerie Gipson Toni Collette as Michelle Sydney Pollack as Stephen Delano Tina Sloan as Mrs. Delano Richard Jenkins as Walter Arnell Akil Walker as Stephen Gipson Cole Hawkins as Danny Gipson Ileen Getz as Ellen Jennifer Dundas as Mina Dunne (as Jennifer Dundas Lowe) Matt Malloy as Ron Cabot Amanda Peet as Cynthia Delano Banek Myra Lucretia Taylor as Judge Frances Abarbanel Bruce Altman as Terry Kaufman Joe Grifasi as Judge Cosell Lisa LeGuillou as Gina Gugliotta (as Lisa Leguillou) Angela Goethals as Sarah Windsor Kevin Sussman as Tyler Cohen Susan Varon as Sheryl Buckburg Noel Wilson as Bartender at Arlo's Angel Caban as Security Guard at School Jim Lovelett as Security Guard at School (as James Lovelett) Julia Gibson as Receptionist at AD&S William Hurt as Doyle's Sponsor Michael McGrath as Seavers (as Michael Patrick McGrath) John Benjamin Hickey as Carlyle Dylan Baker as Finch Ray Bokhour as Willard Suzanne Hevner as Delano's Secretary Caleb Archer as Kid on Bike Jordan Gelber as Priest Olga Merediz as Mrs. Miller Jayne Houdyshell as Miss Tetley Shabazz Ray as Cop at Precinct (as Shabazz Richardson) Raymond Anthony Thomas as Cop at Precinct (as Ray Anthony Thomas) Michael Pitt as Music Teacher / Conductor Genevieve Elam as Waitress Juan Lara as Orchestra Child Anastasia Rojas as Orchestra Child Nicole Wright as Orchestra Child Clive Oliver Greenberg as Orchestra Child Gilbert S. Williams as Mike (as Gil Williams) Sophia Guaspari as Orchestra Member Ruben Jared Seraballs as Orchestra Member (as Ruben J. Seraballs) Father Bonneau as Himself Jewel Brimage as Teacher Katarina Kianna as Teacher Vanessa Quel as Kate Howard I. Laniado as Barry Tony Machine as Office Worker Carolyn Feldschuh as Office Worker Maria Alaina Mason as Office Worker Harvey Waldman as Author in Newsroom Interview Pamela Hart as Newscaster Neal Jones as Newsroom Writer Susan Blackwell as Newsroom Producer Alyson Renaldo as Newsroom Executive Producer James Soviero as Newsroom Associate Producer Mary A. Kelly as Newsroom Script Supervisor (as Mary Kelly) Anthony DiGiacomo as Newsroom Associate Director Richard Velasco as Newsroom Director Leonard L. Thomas as Newsroom Reporter (as Leonard Thomas) Richard Kelly as AA Group Leader Selena Blake as Insurance Broker Harriet Rosenthal as Family Court Member John Kohl as Family Court Member Lisa Vogel as Family Court Member Bob Heffernan as Simon Dunne Myriam Blanckaert as Lawyer (uncredited) Salvatore Cavaliere as Family Court Officer (uncredited) Monet Cunningham as Family Court Member (uncredited) Philip M. Gardiner as Parishoner (uncredited) Ralph Howard as Radio News Anchor, 1010 WINS (voice) (uncredited) Sean T. Krishnan as Sikh (uncredited) Pete Macnamara as Irate Pedestrian (uncredited) Lian Moy as Tourist (uncredited) David C. Roehm Sr. as Defendant in Custody (uncredited) Sam Rovin as Paralegal (uncredited) John H. Tobin as AA Attendee (uncredited) Ray Wineteer as Parishioner (uncredited) Waneeki Yokomee-Fung as Tourist (uncredited)