Artie Lange as Artie DeVanzo Ralph Macchio as Maz Anthony DeSando as Dennis Mangenelli Cara Buono as Linda Salvo Jimmy Palumbo as Johnny Trinno Joe Lo Truglio as Dave Jerry Minor as Tim Seymour Cassel as Dirt Michael Deeg as Alfonse Laurie Metcalf as Artie's Mom Elizabeth Regen as Gina Maddie Corman as Marilyn Frank Pellegrino as Gina's Dad Daniel Tay as Max Keren Gilbert as Vicki Galliotta Alex Corrado as Ed Tina Fey as Front Desk Girl Louis Lombardi as Police Chief Gugliamino Armin Amiri as Steakhouse Waiter Matthew Gumley as Tommy Jodi Lennon as Melissa Jim Breuer as Football Guy Mary Birdsong as Rhonda Nick DiPaolo as Cousin Mickey Jim Florentine as Crispino Erik Martin as Manganelli Catcher George Palermo as Mangenelli First Baseman Christian Sebastiano as Manganelli 2nd Baseman Bret Ernst as Corino Third Baseman Albert DeGrasse as Ed's Bar & Swill Player Jared Burke as Ed's Bar & Swill Player Rich Duva as Ed's Bar & Swill Player Keisha as Pitching Machine Lauren Hugnou as Hooker #1 Maria Javier as Hooker #2 Nathalie Walker as Hooker #3 (as Natalie Twaddle) Charlene Biton as Slap in the Face Hooker (as Kristy Redford) Bill Scheft as Championship Game Ump Mike Lisenco as Umpire #1 (as Michael Lisenco) David Carney as Umpire #2 Kamal Ahmed as Umpire #3 Dana Lorge as Gina's Mom Joanne Joseph as Dirt's Wife Hollie Harper as Tim's Wife Rosalinda Sebastiano as Marie Francisco Sebastiano as Dave's Baby Gino Cafarelli as Dakis George Seminara as Shoot the Geek Barker Todd Barry as Creepy Guy Down the Shore Anya Avaeva as Exotic Dancer (uncredited) Joseph R. Gannascoli as Giusuppe Primavera (uncredited) Shane Geraghty as Softball Player (uncredited) Brigitte Hagerman as One of Dennis Mangenelli's girls (uncredited) John Heinlein as Mangenelli 3rd Baseman (uncredited) Frank Hopf as Manganelli Left Center Fielder (uncredited) Tim Lajcik as Manganelli Outfielder (uncredited) Steve Nuke as 2nd Base Man - Green Team (uncredited) Rich Pecci as Bachleor Party Guy (uncredited) Dana Sironi as (uncredited) Bill Walters as Spectator (uncredited)