Colin Farrell as Jesse James Scott Caan as Cole Younger Ali Larter as Zerelda 'Zee' Mimms Gabriel Macht as Frank James Gregory Smith as Jim Younger Harris Yulin as Thaddeus Rains, President Rock Northern Rail Road Kathy Bates as Ma James Timothy Dalton as Allan Pinkerton Will McCormack as Bob Younger Ronny Cox as Doc Mimms, Zee's Dad Terry O'Quinn as Rollin H. Parker - Rains' Gopher Nathaniel Arcand as Comanche Tom Ty O'Neal as Clell Miller Joe Stevens as Loni Packwood Barry Tubb as Captain Malcolm Jack Watkins as Detective Tom Schuster as Union Officer Lee Ritchey as Bank Manager Robin Christian-McNair as Woman (as Robin Christian) Ed Geldart as Old Man Tucker (Outside Bank) Brad Leland as Sheriff Craig Erickson as Deputy Mark Walters as Engineer Michael Costello as Senator Jack Gould as Head Teller Morgana Shaw as Lyla Brady Coleman as Driver Richard Andrew Jones as Pastor (as Richard Jones) Steven Bland as Man (as Steven 'Dooky' Bland) Jerry Cotton as Teller Muse Watson as Burly Detective Lane Thomas Wilson as Boy Soldier Ron Hayden as Union Lieutenant Darryl Cox as Jenkins Riley Flynn as Union commander Joe Brown as Pinkerton Commander Shawn Patrick Nash as Hangman Jessica M.E. Nitsch as Loni's girl (as Jessica M-E Nitsch) Johnny Bartee as Guitarist (uncredited) Big Skinny Brown as Harlan (uncredited) Pei-San Brown as Saloon Girl (uncredited) Steve Crawford as Troublemaker (uncredited) Frank G. Curcio as Hold-up Victim (uncredited) Lisa Del Dotto as Townsperson (uncredited) Susan E. Denison as Disappointed Girl (uncredited) Jeremy Denzlinger as Hyperion Townsman (uncredited) Troy Dillinger as Pinkerton / Sniper (uncredited) Charles E. Gray as Banker (uncredited) Kirk Hunter as Townsfolk (uncredited) David Jachin Kelley as Sharpshooter (uncredited) Frank Matthews as Pinkerton Detective (uncredited) Rana Morrison as Horserider / Passenger on Train (uncredited) Philip Olivas as Townsfolk (uncredited) Marvin Schroeder as Pinkerton Man (uncredited) Chris Warner as Railroad Worker (uncredited) Paul Wright as Civil War Veteran (uncredited)