Jesse Eisenberg as James Brennan Kelsey Ford as Arlene Michael Zegen as Eric Ryan McFarland as Brad Jack Gilpin as Mr. Brennan Wendie Malick as Mrs. Brennan Matt Bush as Tommy Frigo Todd Cioppa as Velvet Touch Manager Stephen Mast as Rich Kristen Wiig as Paulette Bill Hader as Bobby Martin Starr as Joel Adam Kroloff as Adult Contestant Kristen Stewart as Em Lewin Kevin Breznahan as Molly Hatchet T-Shirt Guy