Tina Fey as Portia Nathan Ann Harada as Mrs. Lafont Ben Levin as Junior Lafont Dan Levy as James (as Daniel Joseph Levy) Maggie Keenan-Bolger as Girl on Tour Gloria Reuben as Corinne Paul Rudd as John Pressman Wallace Shawn as Clarence Elaine Kussack as Abby Christopher Evan Welch as Brandt Michael Genadry as Ben Juliet Brett as Praying Applicant John Brodsky as Smug Kid Camille Branton as Gymnast Sarita Choudhury as Rachael Michael Sheen as Mark Ken Barnett as Admissions Counselor Nat Wolff as Jeremiah Travis Bratten as Quest Student Tanisha Long as Quest Student Nadia Alexander as Quest Student Karen Pham as Quest Student Travaris Spears as Nelson (as Travaris Meeks-Spears) Lily Tomlin as Susannah Rob Campbell as Richard Sonya Walger as Helen Olek Krupa as Polokov Roby Sobieski as Makeout Guy Lauren Schaffel as Student at Party (as Lauren Anne Schaffel) Brian Charles Johnson as Student at Party Lipica Shah as Student at Party Jarod Einsohn as Keg Guy Caliaf St. Aubyn as Keg Guy's Friend Zita Geoffroy as Tour Group Mom (as Zita-Ann Geoffrey) Laura Jordan as Woman Sarah Quinn as Young Mother Jason Blaj as Supermarket Kid Zachary Unger as Jeremiah - 8 Years Old Lisa Emery as Mrs. Pressman Mihran Slougian as Jeremiah's Dad Lynne Taylor as Jeremiah's Mom Brian d'Arcy James as Christopher Flynn Leigha Hancock as Yulia Karasov David Simins as A Capella Singer Brad Wilson as A Capella Singer Ryan McCarty as A Capella Singer Krishna Choudhary as A Capella Singer Ricky Jones as A Capella Singer Thomas Merckens as A Capella Singer Alan Robert Southworth as A Capella Singer Chris Brownell as A Capella Singer Chris Palermo as A Capella Singer Anthony Capers as Jeremiah's Buddy Julia Faye Fisher as Agency Receptionist Gameela Wright as Woman in Adoption Agency Ashlynn Alexander as Sylvia Hadlock (uncredited) James P. Anderson as Baxter Birthday Party Guest (uncredited) Tina Benko as Andrea (uncredited) Paula Blum as Office Administrator (uncredited) Matthew Broadley as Twin Brother (uncredited) Sara Lorena Bruno as (uncredited) Michaela Bryce as Princeton College Applicant (uncredited) Katie Buenneke as Dancing Quest Student (uncredited) Ismael Peter Casillas III as Ismael Cow Milking Expert (uncredited) Ann Chow as Beverly (uncredited) Vanessa Coelho as Quest Student (uncredited) Alix Cross as Quest School Student (uncredited) Jonathon Culver as Quest Student (uncredited) Jeremy Frutkin as Princeton Frat Boy (uncredited) Giullian Yao Gioiello as Princeton Applicant (uncredited) Daniel Grote as Princeton College Applicant (uncredited) Brandon Lee Harris as Office Assistant (uncredited) Alex Hartman as Princeton Applicant (uncredited) Christopher Hopkins-Ward as Quest Student (uncredited) Alice Litvak as Twin Sister (uncredited) Nicole Marie Maggio as Lacrosse Girl (uncredited) Alexis Molnar as Princeton College Applicant (uncredited) Rachel Moss as Lacrosse Player (uncredited) Asher Muldoon as Nelson's Friend (uncredited) Lindsey Ryan as The Applying Student (uncredited) Edward Sass III as Birthday Party Guest (uncredited) Danielle Senk as Lacrosse Player (uncredited) Kelly Southerland as Intern (uncredited) Natasha Tax as Prep School Girl (uncredited) Barbara Vincent as Birthday Party Guest (uncredited) Justice Winter as Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)