Justin Long as Bartleby Gaines Jonah Hill as Sherman Schrader Adam Herschman as Glen Columbus Short as Hands Holloway Maria Thayer as Rory Thayer Lewis Black as Ben Lewis Blake Lively as Monica Mark Derwin as Jack Gaines Ann Cusack as Diane Gaines Hannah Marks as Lizzie Gaines Robin Taylor as Abernathy Darwin Dunlap (as Robin Lord Taylor) Diora Baird as Kiki Joe Hursley as Maurice / The Ringers Jeremy Howard as Freaky Student Anthony Heald as Dean Richard Van Horne