Brian Kerwin as Hal Charli Barcena as Young Tess Peyton List as Young Jane (as Peyton Roi List) Jane Pfitsch as Cousin Lisa Katherine Heigl as Jane Jennifer Lim as Bridal Salesgirl #1 Brigitte Bourdeau as Salesgirl Olga Judy Greer as Casey Danielle Skraastad as Bride Suzanne Marilyn L. Costello as Bride Suzanne's Minister James Marsden as Kevin Michael Ziegfeld as Taxi Driver Khaleel Yetta Gottesman as Hip Bridesmaid Erin Fogel as Shari Rabinowitz Bern Cohen as Rabbi